Count
mutual funds and their investors among
the big losers in the legal battle between
the SEC and The Goldman Sachs Group
Inc.'s broker-dealer unit.
The
10 mutual funds with the biggest investments
in Goldman Sachs shares have seen assets
decline by about $452 million since
the news of the Securities and Exchange
Commission lawsuit broke April 16, according
to data provided by Lipper Inc. Other
fund managers with big percentages of
their assets in Goldman Sachs stock,
including Wells Fargo Funds Management
LLC, The CGM Funds and Matthew 25 Fund
Inc., also have taken hits.
“This is
one of those stocks that everyone
thought was bulletproof,” said
Harry Milling, a mutual fund analyst
who specializes in financial services
at Morningstar Inc.
The suit against
Goldman Sachs alleges that the bank
sold collateralized debt obligations
without telling buyers that a hedge
fund had helped select the subprime
mortgages included in them. The SEC
also claims that the bulge bracket
firm failed to inform investors that
the hedge fund, Paulson & Co.
Inc., was placing bets that the CDOs
would decline in value.
Despite announcing
better-than-expected first-quarter
earnings of $3.3 billion last Tuesday,
Goldman Sachs has seen its stock value
fall 14.6% since the SEC lawsuit was
announced. The stock closed at 184.3
on April 15 — 75 cents below
its highest close of the year April
14 — and fell to 157.4 at the
close April 23.
Among the funds
most heavily invested in Goldman Sachs
stock are The Hartford Financial Services
Group Inc.'s Hartford Capital Appreciation
and Hartford Capital Appreciation
HLS funds, MFS Investment Management's
MFS Value Fund and Fidelity Investments'
Disciplined Equity and Equity Income
funds.
Julia Zweig, a
spokeswoman for The Hartford, and
Dan Flaherty, a spokesman for MFS,
confirmed the data provided by Lipper
but declined to elaborate. Sophie
Launay, a Fidelity spokeswoman, declined
to comment.
Goldman Sachs stock
was the top holding of Wells Fargo's
Advantage Large Company Growth Fund,
which had 8% of assets in the Wall
Street firm as of the end of last
month. Wells Fargo's Advantage Specialized
Financial Services Fund had 6.6% of
its assets invested in Goldman Sachs,
making the stock one of the fund's
top holdings.
“The portfolio
management team of each fund is clearly
aware of the issues impacting these
securities and will make any decisions
with respect to such securities based
upon their individual investment disciplines
and the particular investment policies
of the fund they manage,” said
Peter Greenley, a spokesman for Wells
Fargo Funds.
Some portfolio
managers and financial advisers sold
their holdings in Goldman Sachs months
ago for fear of how financial regulation
and increasing investigation into
the subprime-mortgage meltdown might
affect the firm.
“Everyone
on the Street has been recommending
Goldman, but I didn't own it, because
of the financial reform,” said
the manager of a large-cap-growth
fund, who asked not to be identified.
Jim Flinchum,
a managing principal at Bay Capital
Advisors, which has $40 million in
assets under management, got all his
clients out of Goldman Sachs stock
last month and is reviewing their
mutual fund holdings to see if any
funds have significant holdings in
the firm.
“I
didn't like what was happening with
the financial reform,” Mr. Flinchum
said. “My gut feeling is that
this lawsuit isn't the end of this.”
But not
everyone with holdings in Goldman
Sachs is selling. In fact, a number
of managers are buying the stock,
believing that it is undervalued.
Mark Mulholland,
portfolio manager of the Matthew 25
Fund, which has 6.8% of its assets
invested in the company, is holding
on to the stock. Goldman Sachs is
the fund's third-largest holding.
“I believe
I will make money on it,” said
Mr. Mulholland, who is also president
of Matthew 25. “I believe they
will work through this turmoil.”
Similarly, Harry
Rady, portfolio manager and chief
executive of Rady Asset Management
LLC, has been buying the stock since
it dropped more than $20 on April
16.
“Even if
they have to pay $3 billion over this
suit, it's a drop in the bucket,”
he said. “Goldman is a world-class
franchise, and this is a short-term
transitory event.”
Many industry observers
wonder whether Ken Heebner, portfolio
manager of the CGM Focus Fund, is
holding on to the stock .
Natixis CGM Advisor
Targeted Equity Fund Ticker, which
is a clone of the CGM Focus Fund,
had 8.3% of its assets invested in
Goldman Sachs stock as of Feb 28,
according to Morningstar. The CGM
Focus Fund had 8.2% of its assets
invested in the company at the end
of last year, based on Morningstar's
latest data.
“It's not
surprising that he would have a big
stake in Goldman, because he tends
to make big bets and then trades very
quickly,” said David Kathman,
a mutual fund analyst at Morningstar.
“It's definitely risky to take
bets on a single company.”
Martha Maguire,
a spokeswoman for CGM, declined to
comment.
Although the Goldman
Sachs case may shape the passage of
financial services reform legislation,
managers and analysts think that the
financial services sector is still
a good place for investors to be.
The sector was
the top-performing fund group in the
last quarter, returning 11.5%, according
to Lipper, which also noted that it
was the worst-performing sector over
the past three years, returning -15.2%
annualized.
“Whether
the financial services sector is a
good investment depends on an investor's
time horizon,” said Jeff Tjornehoj,
a senior research analyst at Lipper.
“For six months, it could be
volatile, but for six years, it could
be good.”
E-mail Jessica
Marquez at jmarquez@investmentnews.com.
|